Laura Barr interviews sociologist Andrea Malkin Brenner on college readiness, resilience, and the transition to independence.
Every spring, after the acceptance letters arrive, I hear the same question from thoughtful, invested parents: Is my child actually ready for college?
The applications are done. A decision has been made. But readiness feels less clear. At Emerging Educational Consulting, we believe readiness is a skill that can be cultivated.
To explore what “College Ready” truly means, I spoke with Dr. Andrea Malkin Brenner — sociologist, former American University professor, co-author of the “gold standard” transition guide How to College, and creator of the Talking College™ Card Decks. Andrea has spent years watching what helps students thrive—and what causes them to falter. Watch the full interview here.
Her perspective is reassuring, but not simplistic: If a student has been admitted, the college believes they are capable of succeeding there. That does not mean they are fully independent; it means they are ready to grow into independence within a structured support system.
What Does “College Ready” Really Mean?
College readiness is complex. Colleges do not expect students to arrive polished. They expect first-year students to be in transition. That is why campuses invest heavily in support systems, from Resident Advisors (RAs) to specialized support systems built into first-year seminars, mental health supports etc.
The challenge for most families is adjusting to the shift in expectations between high school and college.
The Biggest Gap: From Structure to Self-Direction
High school is structured for supervision. College is structured for independence. The shift from external accountability to internal regulation is significant. Students must manage long-term planning, time management, and emotional regulation.
Executive functioning—planning, initiating, prioritizing, and following through—becomes central. The interesting fact is that almost all students are under-practiced in independent regulation.
How Parents Should Shift Their Role
Andrea encourages families to consciously shift from “parenting a child” to mentoring a young adult. Mentoring means asking instead of directing and allowing space for problem-solving.
When a student faces a challenge, Andrea suggests responding with: “Tell me what your plan is, and I’ll help you think it through.” This preserves connection while strengthening autonomy—a core tenet of our parental support philosophy.
A 15-Minute Exercise That Clarifies Readiness
Andrea recommends a simple strategy: have the parent and student each spend 15 minutes separately listing what the student needs to learn before move-in.
Comparing these lists often reveals that students focus on abstract tasks (like investing), while parents identify immediate needs: managing prescriptions, budgeting, and self-advocacy with professors. This exercise surfaces blind spots and opens a constructive dialogue.
Where Students Struggle Most in the First Year
Andrea identifies three patterns where students “fail to thrive”:
- Low Resilience: Interpreting normal setbacks as signs they don’t belong.
- Rapid Rescue: Parents solving problems too quickly, preventing the student from building problem-solving capacity.
- Underuse of Resources: Waiting until sophomore year to attend professor office hours, building relationships with career services, and using the mental health resources.
Practical Preparation Before Move-In
Before leaving campus after move-in, walk with your student to the counseling center, the health clinic, the nearest pharmacy, and a grocery store. Familiarity lowers the barrier to seeking help when stress or illness occurs.
Practicing Independence Early
Senior year is the perfect time for “gradual release.”
- Managing their own schedules.
- Scheduling their own appointments.
- Handling minor setbacks independently.
A Structured Resource for Parents
Andrea offers an interactive virtual class series for parents and educators:
- Change Is Coming: Navigating developmental and academic shifts.
- Life Skills Before They Leave: Budgeting, health management, and resilience.
- Defining Your New Role: Moving from protection to mentorship.
Participants receive a Talking College™ prompt deck to guide difficult conversations. Andrea is offering a discount to the Emerging Educational Consulting community.
Frequently Asked Questions About College Readiness
- How do I know if my child is ready for college?
If your child has been admitted, the college believes they can succeed. Readiness reflects a capacity for growth, which we support through our College Expedition services. - What skills matter most before college?
Executive functioning skills, such as time management and self-advocacy, are the strongest predictors of first-year success. - How can parents build resilience?
Allow manageable setbacks and use tools like Dr. Brenner’s Talking College Cards to facilitate adult-to-adult conversations. - Sign up for Emerging’s Executive Function College Transition Program providiing 1:1 support
Sign up for the FREE Parent Community to experience monthly LIVE Podcast episodes, buckets of resources, relevant News articles, and a community of like-minded parents!
Want to learn more about our College Consulting offerings? Tell Us Your Story and we will be in touch!
